Published by C.L. Mike SchmidtSchmidt & Clark, LLP is not currently accepting these types of cases and has posted this content for information purposes only. We encourage you to seek a qualified attorney, if you feel you might have a case.
Although most cases are resolved through guilty pleas, prosecutors and judges may sometimes permit defendants to enter a plea of no contest or nolo contendere.
Both pleas have similar outcomes; the defendant is convicted and penalized in both scenarios.
As an experienced lawyer, I can understand your confusion if you see no difference between these two.
Here’s what you need to know about what makes this particular type of plea so important.
Quick Summary
- Declaring a plea of no contest or nolo contendere is equivalent to stating, "I do not wish to challenge," thus allowing the criminal charge against you to stand.
- Despite the seemingly dishonorable connotations of a no-contest plea, you may have compelling reasons to opt for this rather than pleading guilty.
- Most criminal charges are concluded via plea bargains.
What Is a Plea of No Contest or Nolo Contendere Plea?
A plea of no contest or a nolo contendere plea is when the individual does not admit guilt but agrees to accept a conviction for the crime nonetheless [1].
When a defendant opts for the plea of no contest, in most jurisdictions, the judge must follow these steps:
- Ensure that you comprehend the full details of your plea and its consequences before making a decision.
- Please be advised a no-contest plea is equivalent to a guilty plea in the eyes of the court.
- Make sure you do so freely and not under any persuasion or misunderstanding.
A judge should also tell you that if you plead no contest, it will constitute waiving the rights above. Regarding no-contest pleas and guilty pleas, the primary difference lies in their implications within civil court proceedings.
In most places, a no-contest plea is equal to a guilty plea in terms of felony criminal charges and can be used as an admission of guilt for other legal matters, such as civil cases.
3 Reasons Why to Enter a No Contest Plea
A no-contest plea (nolo contendere) lets you accept the consequences of a criminal charge without admitting guilt.
This legal option can be useful in certain cases, but it is not always the right choice.
Here’s a breakdown of three situations where a no-contest plea might make sense, along with real-life examples and practical guidance.
1. Shield Yourself from Civil Liability
A no-contest plea protects you from admitting guilt in a criminal case, which could later be used against you in civil lawsuits.
- Why It Matters: If you're charged with a crime that might lead to a related civil case, a guilty plea can be seen as an admission of liability. A no-contest plea prevents this, allowing you to resolve the criminal case without jeopardizing your defense in civil court.
- Example: A driver charged with reckless driving after an accident can enter a no-contest plea to avoid automatic liability in a civil suit for damages.
- Best For: Cases with clear civil litigation risks, such as personal injury claims.
Key Considerations
2. Reduce Risks When Conviction is Likely
When the evidence against you is overwhelming, a no-contest plea can help you avoid the uncertainty of trial and negotiate a better outcome.
- Why It Matters: Trials can result in harsher penalties if convicted. Pleading no contest can lead to reduced charges or lighter sentencing as part of a plea deal.
- Example: A business owner accused of embezzlement uses a no-contest plea to secure probation instead of prison time, avoiding the risks of trial.
- Best For: Cases with strong evidence against you, like clear video footage or credible w
itnesses.
3. Resolve Cases Quickly to Save Time and Money
Trials can be emotionally exhausting and financially draining. A no-contest plea offers a quicker resolution, helping you move on with your life.
- Why It Matters: Prolonged legal battles can take a toll on mental health and deplete financial resources. A no-contest plea provides closure without the stress of trial.
- Example: A student charged with shoplifting avoids legal fees and stress by pleading nocontest to a misdemeanor, quickly fulfilling penalties like community service.
- Best For: Those who prioritize fast resolution over fighting charges.
Key Considerations
| Aspect | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Emotional Relief | Reduces emotional and financial strain. | Does not clear your name, leaving charges unresolved. |
| Quick Resolution | Ends legal proceedings sooner, enabling recovery and rebuilding. | Penalties may still affect employment or education opportunities. |
However, it is not always the right choice. Consulting an experienced attorney is essential
to evaluate whether this approach aligns with your circumstances and long-term goals. By understanding the advantages and drawbacks, you can make an informed decision that works best for your situation.
What Happens When You Plead No Contest?
When you plead no contest, the court will find you guilty of the crime and proceed to a sentence. The penalty for pleading no contest is typically the same as if you had pleaded guilty.
This includes a conviction on your criminal record that could affect future job prospects, housing applications, and other areas of life.
When you plead no contest, a judge will assess your case and render a decision accordingly. However, you need to:
- Embrace the plea of no contest and choose not to dispute it.
- Acknowledge the legal consequences and solidify your comprehension when you plead guilty.
- This plea will be held accountable to the same standards as a guilty plea.
- Understand that before you waive your rights as if you are pleading guilty, be sure that this is the best decision for you.
Deciding to plead guilty or no contest means you are forfeiting your right to a jury trial, legal counsel, and the ability to remain silent. Additionally, it means that you cannot question those who have brought accusations against you.
When a defendant enters a no-contest plea in a misdemeanor case, the prosecutor must explain the circumstances of the offense to the judge or magistrate.
-Robert A. Beattey, Former Prosecutor & Civil Litigator
What Rights Do You Waive with a No-Contest Plea?
When you enter a no-contest plea, you give up several critical rights protected under the Constitution. Here's a breakdown of the key rights you forfeit and what it means for your case:
1. Say Goodbye to Trial Rights
- No Jury Trial: You waive the right to have your case heard by a jury.
- No Confronting Witnesses: You forfeit the ability to cross-examine witnesses testifying against you.
2. Limited Grounds for Appeal
- Restricted Appeals: You generally cannot appeal based on trial errors. Appeals are limited to legal issues like ineffective counsel or procedural violations.
3. Impact on Future Cases
- Civil Cases: A no-contest plea cannot be used as an admission of guilt in civil court, but it still creates a criminal conviction that may influence future legal matters.
4. Waiving Constitutional Protections
- Self-Incrimination: By entering this plea, you effectively waive your Fifth Amendment right and accept the court's judgment as if you had admitted guilt.
5. Can You Change Your Mind?
- Withdrawing a Plea: In some cases, you might withdraw your plea before sentencing if you can show good cause, such as misunderstanding the plea's implications.
Common Misconceptions About No-Contest Pleas
Understanding the realities of a no-contest plea is vital to avoid confusion and missteps.
Here are common misconceptions clarified:
Misconception 1: "It Won't Show on My Record"
- Reality: A no-contest plea results in a conviction on your criminal record, just like a guilty plea. This record can impact employment, housing, and other opportunities.
- Example: A defendant pleads no contest to a misdemeanor, thinking it will avoid stigma, only to find it listed on background checks.
Misconception 2: "I Can't Be Sued Civilly"
- Reality: A no-contest plea cannot be used as an admission of guilt in civil court, but it does not prevent lawsuits. Plaintiffs can still sue using other evidence.
- Example: A defendant pleads no contest to a DUI but is later sued by the injured party, who uses crash evidence to prove liability.
Misconception 3: "The Judge Will Be Lenient"
- Reality: Judges are not obligated to reduce penalties for a no-contest plea and often impose standard sentences based on the case facts.
- Example: A defendant enters a no-contest plea hoping for leniency and receives the maximum penalty for their charge.
Misconception 4: "I Can Explain My Side"
- Reality: A no-contest plea typically means the court will not hear your explanation. The prosecution's evidence is accepted as fact.
- Example: A defendant assumes they can explain mitigating circumstances but finds their side is not considered.
Misconception 5: "I Can Withdraw It Later"
- Reality: Once accepted, withdrawing a no-contest plea is challenging and usually requires extraordinary circumstances or legal errors.
- Example: A defendant discovers new evidence after pleading no contest but cannot withdraw the plea.
Civil Implications of a No-Contest Plea
While a no-contest plea avoids some admissions of guilt, it can still have far-reaching effects on civil matters:
Guilty Pleas vs. No Contest Pleas
By entering a not guilty or no contest plea, you are effectively admitting to criminal activity without going through the trial process.
However, this does not preclude potential civil charges from being brought against you - even if you were found "not guilty" in your original case.
If you make a plea bargain with the prosecutor, it is necessary to switch your initial not-guilty plea when seeking approval from the judge.
If you face misdemeanor charges, a plea of no contest will have different consequences than a guilty plea.
However, if the charge is felony-level, most courts handle guilty and no contest pleas similarly; if you plead guilty or "no contest" to a felony, it could be used as an admission of guilt for any related civil proceedings.
No Contest Pleas Comparison with Other Plea Types
Related Articles:
See all related personal injury & accident lawsuits our lawyers have covered.
FAQs
Do I Always Have the Option of Pleading No-Contest?
No, you do not always have the option of pleading no contest. Prosecutors may require that you plead guilty as part of a plea bargain, and it is not always compulsory for judges to accept no-contest pleas.
If I Plead No Contest and Give the Judge a Perfect Excuse, Might the Judge Let Me Off?
No, if you plead no contest and give the judge a perfect excuse, they will not let you off. The judge will only likely find you not guilty on your no-contest plea if there is an error in the "charging" document or a discrepancy between the prosecutor's recitation of facts and those written in the said document.
What Is a Guilty Plea in a Criminal Proceeding?
A guilty plea in a criminal proceeding is an admission of guilt to all or some of the charges in a given criminal case.
Do You Need to Speak With a Criminal Defense Lawyer?
If you find yourself facing a criminal offense, it is essential to seek legal aid. Navigating the often-complicated laws and regulations connected with a civil lawsuit or criminal case can be overwhelming without professional help.
Speak with an experienced criminal defense attorney at Schmidt & Clark, LLP in a free consultation. Our criminal defense lawyers can assist you in comprehending the possible effects of any plea agreement and whether or not this benefits your interests.
Reference:
- https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/no_contest