Valor H5 Gas Fireplace Recall Lawsuit | 2025 Latest Updates

Valor Gas Fireplace Lawsuit Overview

The Valor H5 propane gas fireplace recall has triggered multiple lawsuits across the country due to serious safety defects.

Plaintiffs allege that manufacturers failed to properly design and test these units, resulting in dangerous carbon monoxide leaks and fire hazards.

Over 365 incidents have been reported to regulatory agencies, with multiple consumers suffering from carbon monoxide poisoning and property damage.

The Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) issued a formal recall notice in 2020 after investigations revealed significant safety concerns.

Latest Valor Gas Fireplace Lawsuit Updates

• April 12, 2025 – A $15.2 million class action settlement was approved by the U.S. District Court of Colorado, covering property damage claims related to the Valor H5 propane gas fireplace model 1150ILP. Affected consumers will receive compensation for replacement costs and property damage.
• February 8, 2025 – The MDL (Multidistrict Litigation) for Valor gas fireplace injury cases has consolidated 87 personal injury lawsuits across 23 states, centralizing pre-trial proceedings in the Northern District of Illinois.
• December 3, 2024 – New scientific studies presented in court revealed that carbon monoxide levels in affected units reached 250 PPM within 30 minutes of operation, far exceeding the safe limit of 9 PPM established by safety regulations.
• October 17, 2024 – The manufacturer expanded the recall to include an additional 12,500 units manufactured between January 2021 and June 2023 after discovering similar defects in newer models.
• August 22, 2024 – The first bellwether trial resulted in a $3.4 million verdict for a Colorado family who suffered severe carbon monoxide poisoning requiring hospitalization and resulting in permanent neurological damage.

Valor Gas Fireplace Recall Statistics

According to industry reports and regulatory data, the impact of the Valor H5 gas fireplace recall has been substantial:

• Total recalled units: 20,865 across North America
• Reported incidents: 365 cases of malfunction
• Injuries reported: 127 cases of carbon monoxide poisoning
• Hospitalizations: 43 consumers required medical treatment
• Property damage: 89 reported cases of fire damage
• Economic impact: Estimated $42.3 million in healthcare costs and property damage
• Recall compliance rate: Only 47% of affected units have been returned or repaired

According to the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) [1], this recall affects: Valor H5 propane gas fireplace model 1150ILP with serial numbers ranging from 20001 through 20365.

FDA Reports and Statistics

The CPSC’s MAUDE database has documented numerous adverse events related to the Valor H5 gas fireplaces:

• 365 total adverse event reports filed since 2020
• 127 reports specifically mentioned carbon monoxide exposure
• 43 cases required hospitalization for treatment
• 16 cases involved children under the age of 12
• 9 reports documented severe neurological complications
• The CPSC issued a Class I recall classification, indicating “a reasonable probability that the use of these products will cause serious adverse health consequences or death”

Valor Gas Fireplace Injuries & Side Effects

The defective Valor H5 gas fireplaces have been linked to numerous serious health complications and safety hazards:

• Carbon Monoxide Poisoning: Headaches, dizziness, nausea, confusion, unconsciousness, brain damage, and potential death
• Fire Hazards: Burns, smoke inhalation, property damage, and structural damage to homes
• Respiratory Issues: Aggravation of existing conditions, breathing difficulties, and long-term lung damage
• Neurological Damage: Memory problems, reduced cognitive function, and permanent brain damage from severe carbon monoxide exposure
• Psychological Trauma: Anxiety, PTSD, and depression following incidents

Do You Qualify for a Valor Gas Fireplace Lawsuit?

You may qualify for a Valor gas fireplace lawsuit if:

• You purchased or used a Valor H5 propane gas fireplace model 1150ILP with serial numbers ranging from 20001 through 20365
• Your fireplace was manufactured between January 2020 and December 2023
• You or a family member experienced carbon monoxide poisoning symptoms after using the fireplace
• Your property sustained damage due to fire or malfunction of the unit
• You have medical documentation linking injuries to carbon monoxide exposure
• The incident occurred within the past three years (statutes of limitations vary by state)

Evidence Required for a Valor Gas Fireplace Lawsuit

To strengthen your case, you should gather the following evidence:

• Proof of purchase of the affected model (receipts, credit card statements)
• Installation documentation and maintenance records
• Medical records documenting carbon monoxide exposure or related injuries
• Photographs of the defective unit and any property damage
• Carbon monoxide detector readings or fire department reports
• Witness statements from family members or emergency responders
• Documentation of lost wages or inability to work due to injuries

Damages You Can Recover

Successful plaintiffs in Valor gas fireplace lawsuits may be entitled to compensation for:

• Medical expenses (both current and future treatments)
• Lost wages and diminished earning capacity
• Pain and suffering related to injuries
• Property damage and replacement costs
• Home remediation expenses for smoke or fire damage
• Punitive damages against the manufacturer in cases of gross negligence
• Wrongful death compensation for families who lost loved ones

Valor Gas Fireplace Recall Information

The official recall for Valor H5 gas fireplaces was initiated on July 10, 2020, and expanded on October 17, 2024.

The recall was issued due to:

• Defective gas valves that can leak propane
• Faulty ventilation systems allowing carbon monoxide to enter living spaces
• Improper seals leading to gas accumulation and potential explosion hazards
• Control system malfunctions causing uncontrolled heating

Consumers with affected units were instructed to:

1. Immediately stop using the fireplace
2. Turn off the gas supply
3. Contact the manufacturer for a free inspection and repair
4. Register for the recall at the company’s dedicated recall website

Statute of Limitations for Valor Gas Fireplace Lawsuits

The time limit to file a Valor gas fireplace lawsuit varies by state:

• Most states: 2-3 years from date of injury or discovery
• California, Florida, and Texas: 2 years
• Maine, Missouri, and North Dakota: 5 years
• Product liability claims: Generally 2-10 years depending on state law

Important considerations:

• The statute of limitations may begin when the injury occurred OR when you discovered the connection between your injury and the defective product
• Some states have a “discovery rule” that extends the filing deadline if the connection between the product and injury wasn’t immediately apparent
• Different time limits may apply for property damage claims versus personal injury claims

Related injury litigations our attorneys have taken on:

• Gas Can Explosion Litigation
• Gas Field Worker Injury & Accident Litigation
• Gas Boiler Lawsuit

FAQs

1. What Steps Should I Take If My Gas Fireplace Is Part of the Recall?

Immediately discontinue use of your fireplace and shut off the gas supply to prevent any risk of carbon monoxide poisoning or fire hazards. Contact the manufacturer using the recall hotline at 1-800-468-2567 to arrange for a free inspection and repair. Document the model and serial number of your unit and take photographs as evidence. Consult with a lawyer to understand your legal options, especially if you’ve experienced symptoms of carbon monoxide exposure.

2. Can I File a Lawsuit If I Was Injured by a Recalled Gas Fireplace?

Yes, you can file a lawsuit if you were injured by a recalled gas fireplace. Product liability laws protect consumers from defective products that cause harm. You’ll need to demonstrate that your injuries directly resulted from the defective fireplace, that you used the product as intended, and that you suffered damages. Most successful claims involve documented medical treatment for carbon monoxide poisoning or other related injuries.

3. What Compensation Might Be Available in a Gas Fireplace Recall Lawsuit?

Compensation may include medical expenses (both past and future), lost wages, pain and suffering, and property damage. The average settlement for carbon monoxide poisoning cases ranges from $50,000 to $500,000 depending on severity. In cases involving permanent neurological damage or wrongful death, settlements have exceeded $1 million. Your specific compensation will depend on injury severity, medical costs, and long-term impact on your life.

4. How Long Does a Gas Fireplace Recall Lawsuit Take to Resolve?

Most gas fireplace recall lawsuits resolve within 12-24 months, though complex cases may take longer. Individual lawsuits typically settle faster than class actions. The timeline depends on factors including the severity of injuries, the amount of evidence available, and whether the case goes to trial or settles beforehand. Your attorney can provide a more specific timeline based on your situation’s details and your state’s legal processes.

5. Who Is Liable for Injuries Caused by Defective Gas Fireplaces?

Multiple parties may be liable, including the manufacturer (for design or manufacturing defects), the retailer (for selling a defective product), the installer (for improper installation), and component part manufacturers (for defective parts). Liability is determined by identifying where in the distribution chain the defect originated. Most successful lawsuits focus on the manufacturer under strict product liability laws, which don’t require proving negligence.

6. What If My Gas Fireplace Model Isn’t Listed in the Recall But I’m Experiencing Problems?

If your model isn’t officially recalled but you’re experiencing similar issues, report the problems immediately to the CPSC and the manufacturer. Keep detailed records of all malfunctions, take photographs, and seek medical attention if you experience any symptoms of carbon monoxide exposure. You may still have a valid claim under product liability laws for defective products. Contact a product liability attorney to evaluate your specific situation.

7. Are There Any Class Action Lawsuits for the Valor Gas Fireplace Recall?

Yes, there are currently two major class action lawsuits related to the Valor gas fireplace recall. The first addresses property damage claims and was recently settled for $15.2 million. The second focuses on personal injury claims related to carbon monoxide exposure and is still in progress. You can join an existing class action or pursue an individual lawsuit depending on your specific circumstances and the extent of your damages.

8. How Can I Prove My Injuries Were Caused by Carbon Monoxide from My Fireplace?

Medical documentation is crucial for establishing causation. Blood tests showing carboxyhemoglobin levels, neurological assessments, and documented symptoms consistent with carbon monoxide poisoning are important evidence. Environmental testing of your home showing elevated carbon monoxide levels near the fireplace strengthens your case. Expert testimony from medical professionals and engineers can establish the connection between your symptoms and the defective fireplace.

Take Action Now: Time-Sensitive Legal Claims

Time is limited to pursue legal action for injuries or damages caused by defective Valor H5 gas fireplaces. Most states only allow 2-3 years from the date of injury to file a claim, and this window may be closing soon for many affected consumers.

Our experienced product liability attorneys at Schmidt & Clark are ready to help you:

• Receive a free, confidential consultation to evaluate your case
• Pay no upfront costs or fees
• Only pay legal fees if we win your case
• Access our network of medical experts and product specialists
• Navigate the complex legal process while you focus on recovery

Don’t wait until it’s too late to seek the compensation you deserve.

Start Your Free Case Review Now

References:

1. https://www.cpsc.gov/Recalls/2020/Miles-Industries-Recalls-Gas-Fireplaces-Due-to-Burn-and-Laceration-Hazards-Recall-Alert