Schmidt & Clark, LLP is not currently accepting these types of cases and has posted this content for information purposes only. We encourage you to seek a qualified attorney, if you feel you might have a case.
What is a Butterfly Knife?
Also known as a balisong or fan knife, a butterfly knife is a type of folding pocketknife that originated in the Philippines. The knife features 2 handles counter-rotating around the tang such that, when closed, the blade is concealed within grooves in the handles.
Related Article: What's the Difference Between a Dirk and a Dagger?
What is the Purpose of a Butterfly Knife?
Butterfly knives can be opened quickly with one hand and are easily used as a weapon. They are commonly used for self-defense and utility purposes.
Are Butterfly Knives Illegal in California? Real Cases and Legal Consequences
In California, the possession of butterfly knives is illegal under Penal Code Section 21510, which classifies them as switchblades due to their quick-opening mechanism.
Violating this law is considered a misdemeanor, carrying penalties of up to six months in county jail and/or a fine of up to $1,000.
Why are Butterfly Knives Illegal in California?
Butterfly knives are illegal in California because of their potential for use as a threatening weapon. A person with experience can deploy butterfly knives with immense speed, which may be the knife's most dangerous quality.
Case Example: People v. Quon
In People v. Quon, the defendant was found in possession of a butterfly knife during a routine traffic stop in California.
He was charged under Penal Code Section 21510 for possessing an illegal switchblade. The court upheld the charge, emphasizing that butterfly knives fall under the state's definition of prohibited weapons due to their potential for rapid deployment.
Prosecution Statistics
Understanding the legal status and enforcement of butterfly knife bans in different states helps provide clarity on the risks associated with possession. Below is a breakdown of how California and Hawaii handle these laws and recent legal developments that could influence future regulations.
California
- Legality: Possessing a butterfly knife in California is classified as a misdemeanor offense, punishable by up to six months in county jail and/or a $1,000 fine. However, many offenders receive misdemeanor probation instead of jail time.
- Enforcement: While specific statewide prosecution statistics are not available, the law is actively enforced to ensure compliance and public safety.
Hawaii
- Legality: Similar to California, Hawaii prohibits the manufacture, sale, transport, or possession of butterfly knives. Violations are misdemeanors, carrying potential legal consequences.
- Enforcement: Law enforcement agencies have actively prosecuted butterfly knife offenses, with at least 30 individuals arrested or cited since 2012 [1].
Recent Developments
- Legal Challenges: A recent Ninth Circuit ruling has challenged butterfly knife bans, which could potentially impact California’s restrictions if upheld.
- Multistate Support: California Attorney General Rob Bonta has joined Hawaii in defending its ban, advocating for a rehearing in the Ninth Circuit to maintain the legal precedent.
It's crucial for residents and visitors in California to be aware of these regulations to avoid legal repercussions.
If you're found in possession of a butterfly knife, you could face criminal charges, underscoring the importance of understanding and adhering to state weapon laws.
Also Read: Spring-Assist Knives in California: Legal or Not in 2024?
Penalties for Carrying a Butterfly Knife in California
Possessing a butterfly knife in California is a misdemeanor crime. Convictions can result in up to 6 months in county prison and/or $1,000 in fines.
However, many of these instances result in misdemeanor probation, also known as summary probation, which means the accused will not have to serve any time in prison. The sentence would instead be spent under community supervision.
Common Defenses in Butterfly Knife Cases
If you have been charged with possession of a butterfly knife in California, there are several legal defenses that may help reduce or dismiss your charges.
Since these cases often depend on circumstances of possession, intent, and law enforcement conduct, an experienced defense attorney can explore multiple strategies to fight the charges.
1. Lack of Knowledge
One of the most effective defenses is proving that you were unaware the knife was illegal or did not know you were in possession of a butterfly knife.
For example:
- The knife was found in a shared vehicle or borrowed bag, meaning you may not have knowingly possessed it.
- You mistakenly believed the knife was legal, especially if purchased from an online retailer that did not specify California's restrictions.
2. Unlawful Search and Seizure
If the butterfly knife was discovered during an illegal search by law enforcement, the evidence could be suppressed, leading to case dismissal.
Examples of illegal searches include:
- Being stopped without reasonable suspicion
- Police searching your property without a warrant or consent
3. Knife Classification Dispute
Not all folding or flipping knives qualify as illegal butterfly knives under California law.
A strong defense may argue that:
- The knife does not meet the legal definition of a butterfly knife (e.g., requires two hands to open, does not have a spring mechanism).
- Law enforcement misidentified the knife.
4. Temporary Possession or Lack of Ownership
If you were briefly in possession of the knife but did not own it, your attorney may argue:
- You were holding it for someone else and were not aware of its legal status.
- The knife belonged to another person, and you had no intent to keep or use it.
Plea Bargaining Possibilities
For individuals facing charges, plea bargaining may be an option to reduce penalties or avoid a conviction altogether.
Potential plea deals include:
- Reducing the charge to a lesser offense, such as simple possession of a legal knife.
- Agreeing to probation instead of jail time.
- Deferred judgment programs, where the case is dismissed if the defendant completes community service or other conditions.
Since many butterfly knife cases result in misdemeanor probation, working with an experienced attorney can improve the chances of negotiating a favorable outcome rather than facing maximum penalties.
Related Article: Is Drinking in Public Illegal in California?
Are Butterfly Knives Illegal in All 50 States?
The only federal law pertaining to butterfly knives is US Code Title 15, Chapter 29, which controls the importation of the knives into the United States, and the sale over state lines. It has no effect on buying, owning, or carrying butterfly knives. Such is left to the states.
Related Article: Open Carry in California
What Other Knives are Illegal in California?
Generally speaking, knives that are illegal in California are those which are most commonly used to commit crimes and do not have an obvious use as a tool or look like knives.
In addition to butterfly knives, knives that are illegal to possess in California include:
- Cane knives
- Air gauge knives
- Lipstick knives
- Belt buckle knives
- Writing pen knives
- Switchblades with a blade longer than 2”
- Ballistic knives
What Can I Use Instead? Legal Everyday Carry (EDC) Options in California
While butterfly knives are illegal in California, there are plenty of legal alternatives that provide similar utility and convenience.
If you are looking for an EDC knife that complies with California law, here are some practical options:
1. Folding Knives (Legal to Carry Concealed)
Under California Penal Code Section 17235, all folding knives are legal as long as they do not lock in the open position automatically.
Examples of Legal Folding Knives:
- Swiss Army knives
- Box cutters
- Utility knives
- Traditional pocket knives (e.g., Buck 110, Spyderco Delica)
The knife must be in the closed position when carried concealed. There is no blade length restriction for standard folding knives.
2. Fixed-Blade Knives (Must Be Openly Carried)
California allows fixed-blade knives (such as hunting or survival knives), but they cannot be concealed on your person. They must be carried openly in a sheath on your belt.
Legal Fixed-Blade Options:
- Kitchen knives
- Hunting knives
- Bowie knives
- Machetes
Concealed carry of fixed-blade knives is illegal and considered a misdemeanor.
3. Assisted-Opening Knives (Legal if Not Fully Automatic)
- Assisted-opening knives, such as the Kershaw Blur or Benchmade Barrage, are legal as long as they require manual pressure to fully open.
- Switchblades (automatic knives with blades over 2 inches) are illegal in California.
Traveling with Knives: State-by-State Differences
Knife laws vary widely from state to state, which is important if you plan to travel with an EDC knife.
For example:
- Nevada allows butterfly knives, while California bans them.
- Arizona has few knife restrictions, allowing concealed carry of almost all knives.
- New York has strict switchblade and gravity knife laws.
The TSA prohibits carrying knives in carry-on luggage. However, you can pack knives in checked baggage as long as they are securely sheathed.
To stay compliant, always check state and local knife laws before traveling with any type of knife.
FAQs
1. Can I Legally Carry A Butterfly Knife For Self-Defense In California?
No, carrying a butterfly knife for self-defense is illegal in California. Possession alone can lead to criminal charges.
2. Are There Any Exceptions To The Ban On Butterfly Knives In California?
There are no specific exceptions mentioned in California law; manufacturing, selling, or possessing butterfly knives is generally prohibited.
3. Can I Face Charges For Selling Butterfly Knives Online To Someone In California?
Yes, selling butterfly knives to a person in California, whether online or in-person, is illegal and can result in criminal charges.
4. Why are Butterfly Knives So Dangerous?
Butterfly knives can be extremely dangerous because one edge of the blade is sharp and will cut the user if they are not careful, especially when flipping the knife.
Related Articles:
See all related personal injury and accident cases our lawyers have covered.
Need Legal Help? Get a Free Case Evaluation
While the Schmidt & Clark, LLP law firm is not currently handling butterfly knife-related cases, we are actively representing clients in other personal injury and product liability lawsuits nationwide.
If you or a loved one has suffered an injury and need legal support, our team can provide a free consultation to discuss your options.
If you need assistance with a different legal matter, contact us today to see how we can help.
Published by