Published by Schmidt & Clark, LLP is not currently accepting these types of cases and has posted this content for information purposes only. We encourage you to seek a qualified attorney, if you feel you might have a case.
What is a Workplace Investigation?
A workplace investigation is a formal process conducted to uncover facts about alleged incidents at work, such as policy violations, misconduct, harassment, or safety concerns.
The goal is to ensure a fair assessment by reviewing evidence, interviewing relevant parties, and maintaining confidentiality.
Workplace investigations aim to reach an informed conclusion protecting employees' rights and company standards.
Types of Workplace Investigations
Workplace investigations can cover various issues, each aiming to ensure a fair and compliant work environment.
Some common types include:
- Harassment & Discrimination: Addressing complaints of inappropriate behavior or bias.
- Misconduct: Investigating violations like theft, fraud, or breach of company policy.
- Health & Safety: Examining incidents related to workplace safety or injury.
- Performance Issues: Assessing cases of chronic absenteeism or poor job performance.
Each type of investigation follows unique protocols based on the nature of the issue and relevant laws.
Two Common Scenarios that Warrant a Workplace Investigation
There are two common scenarios that often prompt a workplace investigation:
Being discriminated against in the workplace means that an employer takes adverse action against you because of one of the following attributes:
- race
- color
- sex
- sexual orientation
- age
- physical or mental disability
- marital status
- family or carer responsibility
- pregnancy
- religion
- political opinion
- national extraction or social origin.
An investigation of a formal complaint of discrimination is an official inquiry into claims raised in a complaint to the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC).
These investigations may include numerous fact-finding methods, including interviews, a fact-finding conference, requests for information, interrogatories, and affidavits.
2. Bullying
Workplace bullying is repeated and unreasonable behavior directed toward an employee that creates a risk to health and safety.
This behavior is a risk because it may affect workers' mental and physical health. Taking steps to prevent workplace bullying from occurring and responding quickly if it does is the best way to deal with workplace bullying.
Examples include:
- verbal abuse
- sabotage of work efforts
- spreading harmful rumors
- excessive monitoring
This conduct can cause stress, anxiety, or even physical health issues for the targeted individual.
Employees have the right to report bullying without retaliation, to access mental health resources if affected, and to expect their employer to address complaints seriously.
Employers who ignore workplace bullying may face EEOC law violations, underscoring the need for prompt and effective intervention.
Related Article: When Not to Sign a Severance Agreement?
Why Workplace Investigations are Biased Toward the Employer
The employer conducts internal workplace investigations to determine the company's liability, which is why these investigations are usually biased toward the employer.
The employer desires the investigation to reveal no violations of any employee’s legal rights. There is no incentive for the investigators to continue the investigation to find the truth.
In these situations, investigators may not be motivated to explore evidence that proves a violation or contradicts the employer’s narrative. This bias makes it hard for workers to get a fair hearing during an internal investigation. As an employee, you need someone to advocate for your legal rights.
Remote Work Investigations: What to Expect
As remote work becomes increasingly common, employers may conduct investigations related to employee conduct, performance, or compliance with company policies in a virtual environment.
Understanding what to expect during these investigations is crucial for employees. Here’s a comprehensive guide on the process, employee rights, and best practices.
What Triggers a Remote Work Investigation?
Investigations may be initiated for various reasons, including:
- Allegations of Misconduct: Reports of inappropriate behavior, harassment, or unethical practices.
- Performance Issues: Concerns about productivity or failure to meet job expectations.
- Policy Violations: Breaches of company policies regarding confidentiality, data security, or remote work guidelines.
What to Expect During the Investigation
During a workplace investigation, employees can anticipate a structured process to gather all relevant facts and ensure a fair outcome. From initial notifications to interviews and evidence reviews, each stage has specific procedures designed to uphold confidentiality and thoroughness.
Here’s what employees should expect at each phase of the investigation:
- Notification: Employees will typically receive a notification from HR or management regarding the investigation. This notification may outline the nature of the investigation and any preliminary findings.
- Interviews: Employees may be interviewed as part of the investigation. This could include discussions with the employee under investigation and interviews with colleagues or supervisors with relevant information.
- Document Review: Investigators may review emails, chat logs, and other digital communications to gather evidence related to the allegations. Employees should be aware that their online activities might be scrutinized.
- Confidentiality: Investigations are generally conducted confidentially to protect the privacy of all parties involved. Employees should refrain from discussing the investigation with colleagues to avoid spreading misinformation.
- Timeline: The duration of an investigation can vary based on its complexity and the number of individuals involved. Employees should be informed about expected timelines but should understand that some delays may occur.
Remote work investigations can be complex and stressful for employees. Understanding what triggers these investigations, what to expect during the process, and knowing your rights, you can navigate this challenging situation more effectively.
Your Rights as an Employee During a Workplace Investigation
During a workplace investigation, employees have specific rights to ensure fair treatment and respect for their privacy. Knowing these rights can help employees navigate the process with clarity and confidence.
Employee rights include:
- Privacy: Protection of personal and sensitive information.
- Representation: Right to have a union rep, attorney, or advocate present.
- Transparency: Understanding the allegations to respond effectively.
- Non-Retaliation: Safeguards against unfair treatment due to participation.
Knowing these rights empowers employees to navigate investigations confidently. Understanding these rights can help maintain a balanced approach, even when work is conducted remotely.
Immediate Steps to Take During a Workplace Investigation
When an investigation starts, stay calm, understand your rights, and approach the process professionally.
1. Stay Calm and Professional- Compose Yourself
Avoid gossip and focus on your work duties to maintain a positive impression. Maintain professionalism throughout the process, regardless of personal feelings about the situation.
2. Understand Your Rights- Review Policies
Check company policies or the employee handbook for specific procedures.
3. Document Everything- Record Key Details
Keep notes on interactions related to the investigation and collect relevant documents. Maintaining thorough documentation is essential in an investigation.
Employees should keep records of communication with supervisors or HR, key dates, emails, relevant documents, and any personal notes on interactions related to the case.
4. Seek Clarification- Ask Questions
If unclear about any aspect of the investigation or your rights, seek clarification from HR or legal counsel.
5. Consider Legal Counsel- Protect Yourself
If you believe your rights are being violated or face potential disciplinary action, consider consulting an attorney specializing in employment law.
6. Prepare for Interviews- Stay Honest
Be factual and accurate in interviews or discussions related to the investigation.
Following these steps helps protect your rights and confidently navigate the investigation process.
FAQs
What rights do employees have during a workplace investigation?
Employees have the right to be informed of the investigation, to respond to allegations, to be treated fairly and without bias, and to have a representative present during interviews. They also have the right to confidentiality and protection against retaliation.
Can an employee refuse to participate in a workplace investigation?
Employees can refuse to participate in a workplace investigation, but this may lead to disciplinary action or affect the outcome of the investigation. It’s generally advisable to cooperate while ensuring your rights are protected.
Are employees entitled to see the results of a workplace investigation?
Employees are not always entitled to see the full results of a workplace investigation, but they should be informed of the outcome and any actions taken as a result. Employers are generally required to maintain confidentiality throughout the process.
Can I have a lawyer present during a workplace investigation?
While you generally have the right to have a representative present during a workplace investigation, whether a lawyer can be present depends on the company’s policies. Consult with your HR department or an employment attorney for guidance.
Related Article: Signs & Examples of a Hostile Work Environment
Get a Free Lawsuit Evaluation With Our Lawyers
The Litigation Group at Schmidt & Clark, LLP law firm is an experienced team of trial lawyers focusing on plaintiffs' representation in lawsuits. We are handling individual litigation nationwide and currently accepting new legal challenges in all 50 states.
If you or a loved one was involved with such matters, you should contact Schmidt & Clark, LLP immediately for a free case evaluation. You may be entitled to a settlement by filing a suit, and we can help.