FREE Case Review (866) 588-0600

What is a Motion to Stay a Sentence Pending Appeal?

A motion to stay a sentence pending appeal is a legal request asking the court to temporarily suspend the execution of a sentence while the defendant’s appeal is being considered. If granted, the defendant would not have to serve their sentence until the appeal is resolved. This motion is typically filed to avoid potential harm or unnecessary punishment if the appeal could result in a reversal or modification of the sentence.
Awards & recognition
Published by Rabb

Understanding a Stay of Proceedings in Court

“A stay of proceedings is a ruling by a court to stop or suspend a proceeding or trial temporarily or indefinitely. A court may later lift the stay and continue the proceeding” [1.].

While some stays occur automatically, others are granted at the court’s discretion. Typically, an appeal will stay proceedings in the lower court.

In Long v. Robinson, 432 F.2d 977 (4th Cir. 1970), the court established that to obtain a stay, a party must demonstrate:

  • A strong likelihood of success on the merits of the appeal.
  • The potential for irreparable harm if the stay is not granted.
  • That the stay will not cause significant harm to the other parties involved.
  • That granting the stay aligns with the public interest.

A stay is crucial for maintaining the status quo between parties during an appeal, ensuring that the appellate court’s decision will have a meaningful impact. By preserving the current conditions, the stay prevents any changes that could render the appeal moot, especially in cases where immediate action could cause irreversible harm [2.].

A stay is particularly necessary when the appellant can demonstrate potential irreparable harm without it. For example, in environmental disputes, if a plaintiff loses at trial but appeals the decision, a stay can prevent the defendant from developing land and causing environmental damage before the appeal is resolved. Without a stay, any subsequent appellate victory may be meaningless if the harm has already occurred.

“A stay lifts the obligation for the losing party to immediately comply with the judgment. However, neither side should assume a stay will automatically be granted. In most cases, it won’t.”

How to Obtain a Stay

Certain trial court decisions may be automatically stayed when an appeal is filed. In California, for example, declaratory judgments often receive an automatic stay. However, automatic stays are not guaranteed, and obtaining a stay may require additional legal action.

To stay the enforcement of a judgment, the losing party can file a writ of supersedeas. This writ must be served on the opposing parties and should clearly outline the necessity of the stay, supported by a memorandum citing relevant legal authority and arguments. The appeal must be pending, meaning the notice of appeal has been timely filed, and the appellant must have exhausted all available options at the trial court level before seeking a writ of supersedeas.

“The appellate court has broad authority to grant or reject a writ of supersedeas. If a stay is issued, the appellate court must notify the trial court.”

Understanding an Appeal: What It Is and How It Works

An appeal is a legal process in which an appellate court reviews the proceedings of a trial court to determine if any procedural errors were made [3.]. This review is strictly based on the written records from the trial court, and no new evidence is introduced.

The appellate court does not reassess the guilt or innocence of the defendant (referred to as the “appellant” in this context); instead, it evaluates whether the trial was conducted fairly and whether the correct legal rulings were applied.

The appellate court has several options when deciding an appeal. It can affirm the lower court’s judgment, leaving the decision unchanged, or modify the judgment, potentially altering aspects like sentencing. The court may also reverse the judgment in part or entirely, often resulting in the case being sent back to the trial court for a retrial.

In rare cases, the court may reverse the judgment with instructions to dismiss the case altogether. A reversal generally means the appellant is entitled to a new trial or hearing in the lower court.

Also read: Workers’ Comp Appeal Wait Time

“After the Court of Appeal has made its decision, either party can petition for a hearing in the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court has a different role from that of the Court of Appeal. Whereas the Court of Appeal reviews every appeal for error, the Supreme Court grants review in only a very few cases which present legal issues of statewide importance.”

Get a Free Lawsuit Evaluation With Our Lawyers

The Litigation Group at Schmidt & Clark, LLP is an experienced team of trial lawyers that focuses on the representation of plaintiffs in lawsuits. We are handling individual litigation nationwide and are currently accepting new legal challenges in all 50 states.

If you or a loved one was involved with these matters, you should contact our law firm immediately for a free case evaluation. You may be entitled to a settlement by filing a suit and we can help.

References:
1. https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/stay_of_proceedings
2. https://www.gusdorfflaw.com/how-to-stay-a-judgment-pending-appeal/
3. https://sdap.org/starting-an-appeal/how-an-appeal-works/

Free Confidential Case Evaluation

Verified 100% Secure SiteTo contact us for a free review of your potential case, please fill out the form below or call us toll free 24 hrs/day by dialing: (866) 588-0600.