Published by Schmidt & Clark, LLP is not currently accepting these types of cases and has posted this content for information purposes only. We encourage you to seek a qualified attorney, if you feel you might have a case.
What are 5 Ways to Get Felony Charges Dropped
Facing felony charges can be overwhelming, but there are legal strategies that may help you get them dropped. Whether due to insufficient evidence, constitutional violations, or plea negotiations, the right legal approach can significantly impact the outcome of your case.
Below are five common methods used to have felony charges dismissed, along with real-world examples, success rates, and case citations.
1. Insufficient Evidence: Challenging the Prosecution's Case
One of the most common reasons felony charges are dropped is lack of sufficient evidence. Prosecutors must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a defendant committed the alleged crime. If evidence is weak or key witnesses are unavailable, charges may not hold up in court.
How This Works:
Your attorney can file a motion to dismiss if evidence is lacking. If a witness refuses to testify or crucial evidence is ruled inadmissible, the prosecution may be forced to drop the charges.
Real-World Example: A theft case in California was dismissed after the defense successfully argued that security footage was too blurry to identify the suspect, and no other solid evidence supported the prosecution's case.
Success Rate: Cases dismissed due to insufficient evidence are common in criminal defense and often occur before trial. If evidence is weak, prosecutors are unlikely to proceed.
Timeframe: Can be resolved within weeks or months in the pretrial phase.
2. Proving Constitutional Violations: Unlawful Police Conduct
If law enforcement violates your constitutional rights, the charges against you may be dropped. The U.S. Constitution protects you from illegal searches, coerced confessions, and denial of legal representation.
The United States Constitution protects you from coercive police tactics, including:
- The right to be free from self-incrimination
- The right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures
- The right to legal representation during interrogations
- The right to cross-examine the witnesses at a preliminary hearing against you
- The right to see the evidence against you
Common Constitutional Violations
- Illegal Search & Seizure (Fourth Amendment) – If police obtained evidence without a valid warrant, that evidence can be thrown out.
- Self-Incrimination Protection (Fifth Amendment) – Coerced confessions cannot be used in court.
- Right to Legal Representation (Sixth Amendment) – If you were denied access to an attorney, the case could be dismissed.
Real-World Example: In Mapp v. Ohio (1961), the Supreme Court ruled that evidence obtained illegally cannot be used in court, leading to a major shift in how search and seizure laws are applied.
Success Rate: If a defense attorney successfully proves a constitutional rights violation, the case may be dismissed. Judges often exclude unlawfully obtained evidence, making it impossible for the prosecution to continue.
Timeframe: Typically handled in pretrial motions and can take several months to resolve.
3. Negotiating a Plea Agreement
A plea deal allows defendants to plead guilty to a lesser charge in exchange for dropping the felony charge. While this does not always result in complete dismissal, it significantly reduces penalties.
How This Works
- Prosecutors offer a reduced charge to avoid the risk of trial.
- The defendant pleads guilty to a lesser offense (e.g., misdemeanor instead of a felony).
- This eliminates the risk of severe felony penalties such as long-term prison sentences.
Real-World Example: A person facing felony drug possession charges might agree to plead guilty to a misdemeanor possession charge with probation, avoiding a permanent felony record.
Success Rate: Plea deals are one of the most common resolutions in felony cases. Many defendants avoid serious penalties through skillful negotiations.
Timeframe: Plea negotiations often occur within weeks or months after an arraignment.
4. Cooperating with Prosecutors in Another Case
Prosecutors may drop felony charges in exchange for a defendant’s cooperation in another investigation.
This often happens in organized crime, drug trafficking, or fraud cases where a lower-level defendant provides testimony or information against a more significant target.
How This Works
- Testifying against a co-defendant or criminal organization member.
- Providing inside information that helps law enforcement.
- Assisting in ongoing investigations to uncover more serious crimes.
Real-World Example: In United States v. Gigante, a defendant cooperated with federal prosecutors in exchange for a reduced sentence after testifying against a major organized crime figure.
Success Rate: Highly effective if the defendant provides valuable cooperation. Prosecutors will only offer a deal if the information is substantial.
Timeframe: This process can take several months to over a year, depending on the investigation's complexity.
5. Participating in a Pretrial Diversion Program
A pretrial diversion program allows defendants to avoid a felony conviction by completing supervised programs such as community service, counseling, or rehabilitation.
The program diverts you out of the criminal justice system and into supervised release or probation. If you complete the diversion program, your felony case will be dismissed.
How Pretrial Diversion Works
- Eligibility: Typically for first-time offenders or non-violent felony charges.
- Supervised Release: Must complete court-ordered requirements (e.g., drug rehab, probation, or anger management).
- Dismissal of Charges: Upon completion, the felony charge is dropped.
Real-World Example: A first-time offender facing felony drug possession was offered a one-year rehab program. After successfully completing treatment, the court dismissed the charges.
Success Rate: Pretrial diversion programs have high success rates for eligible defendants. Most participants successfully avoid conviction if they comply with program conditions.
Timeframe: Programs typically last between 6 months and 2 years, depending on the nature of the offense.
Related Articles
:
- How Long Does It Take To Get a Court Date for a Felony?
- Understand the Pros & Cons of a No Contest Plea
- How Long Does Felony Stay on Your Record?
What You Need to Know When Facing Felony Charges
Being charged with a felony is a serious legal matter that requires a well-planned defense. Understanding your rights, legal options, and the strategies available to fight the charges can significantly impact your case.
Whether you are facing state or federal charges, knowing how to proceed can mean the difference between conviction and dismissal.
First Steps After Being Charged
The first actions you take after being charged can shape the outcome of your case.
- Exercise Your Right to Remain Silent – Under the Fifth Amendment, you are not required to answer police questions without an attorney present. Anything you say can and will be used against you, so remaining silent is often the best course of action.
- Secure Legal Representation – Whether hiring a private defense attorney or requesting a court-appointed lawyer, getting legal counsel immediately is crucial. A skilled attorney will help you understand the severity of your charges and begin building a defense.
- Understand the Charges Against You – Every felony case is different, and knowing the specific laws you are accused of breaking is essential. Some felonies come with mandatory sentencing guidelines, while others may offer room for negotiation.
Statute of Limitations: Could Your Charges Be Dismissed?
In some cases, felony charges can be dismissed if too much time has passed since the alleged offense. Each state has a statute of limitations, which dictates how long prosecutors have to file charges.
If the deadline has expired, your attorney may be able to get the case thrown out immediately. However, some crimes—such as murder—have no statute of limitations.
Key Documentation for Your Defense
Gathering the right evidence is essential when working on your defense. The stronger your supporting documents, the better your chances of getting charges dropped or reduced.
- Discrediting the Prosecution’s Case – Any evidence that contradicts the allegations, such as surveillance footage, emails, or forensic reports, can weaken the case against you.
- Witness Statements – If someone can verify that you were not at the scene of the crime or dispute the prosecution’s claims, their testimony may be crucial.
- Police Misconduct Evidence – If law enforcement violated your rights (e.g., an illegal search or coerced confession), this evidence can support a motion to dismiss the charges.
Understanding the Differences Between State and Federal Felony Charges
Not all felonies are prosecuted the same way. Some cases are handled at the state level, while others fall under federal jurisdiction.
| Aspect | State Charges | Federal Charges |
|---|---|---|
| Jurisdiction | Crimes committed within state boundaries | Federal laws or crimes that cross state lines |
| Prosecution | Handled by local district attorneys | Prosecuted by U.S. Attorneys |
| Penalties | Sentences vary by state | Often stricter, with longer prison terms |
| Court System | State courts | Federal courts |
Because federal cases are prosecuted by well-funded government attorneys, defendants in federal cases often face a tougher legal battle.
However, this does not mean state felony charges should be taken lightly—both require a strong defense strategy.
How Felony Charges Can Impact Your Future
A felony conviction can have life-altering consequences beyond just jail time.
If convicted, you may face:
- Loss of Professional Licenses – Doctors, nurses, teachers, and other licensed professionals often lose their credentials after a felony conviction.
- Deportation for Non-Citizens – Under immigration law, certain felonies are classified as “aggravated felonies”, which can lead to immediate deportation. If you are a non-citizen, consulting an immigration attorney is essential.
- Employment Challenges – Many employers conduct background checks, and a felony record can limit job opportunities.
For these reasons, fighting felony charges is about more than avoiding prison—it’s about protecting your future.
See all related personal injury lawsuits our attorneys covered so far.
FAQs
1. What Role Does an Alibi Play?
Providing a solid alibi that proves the defendant was not present at the crime scene can lead to charges being dropped.
2. How Can Mental Health Issues Impact the Case?
Demonstrating that the defendant has significant mental health issues may lead to charges being dropped or reduced to seek appropriate treatment instead of punishment.
3. Is It Possible to Get Felony Charges Dropped After an Indictment?
Yes, with strong legal arguments and evidence, it is possible to get felony charges dropped even after an indictment.
Get a Free Lawsuit Evaluation With Our Lawyers
The Litigation Group at Schmidt & Clark, LLP law firm is an experienced team of trial lawyers focusing on plaintiffs' representation in lawsuits. We are handling individual litigation nationwide and currently accepting new legal challenges in all 50 states.
If you or a loved one was involved with such matters, you should contact Schmidt & Clark, LLP immediately for a free case evaluation. You may be entitled to a settlement by filing a suit and we can help.