FREE Case Review (866) 588-0600

Bakken Formation Lawsuit:
Oil Leasing in 2024

Awards & recognition
C.L. Mike Schmidt Published by C.L. Mike Schmidt
Free Consultation
If you or a loved one think you may have a claim, you should contact a personal injury lawyer immediately.

You may be entitled to recover compensation and our legal team can help. Please click the button below for a Free Consultation or call us toll-free 24 hrs/day for legal advice by dialing (866) 588-0600.

Start My Free Case Evaluation

The Bakken Formation lawsuit is an ongoing legal battle that has captured headlines and divided opinions. The lawsuit has raised crucial questions about the future of oil leasing and environmental protection in the United States. 

As a legal attorney with almost a decade of experience, I will provide insights into the intricacies of this lawsuit, the key players involved, and the potential implications for the energy industry and local communities.

Quick Summary

  • The Bakken Formation lawsuit involves numerous stakeholders in a dispute over oil leasing and property rights.
  • The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled to dismiss the case, with potential implications for economic growth, environmental protection, tax revenues, and local communities in North Dakota’s Bakken Shale region.
  • The average settlement amount in the lawsuit varies widely, but some settlements have been reported to be millions of dollars.

What Is The Bakken Shale Formation Lawsuit?

A man reading the Bakken Shale formation lawsuit

The Bakken Shale Formation lawsuit is about the fight for property rights and “pore space.” The lawsuit’s primary focus pertains to Senate Bill 2344, which permits the utilization of subsurface geologic formations (pore space) for CO2-enhanced oil recovery efforts and prevents the owners of the pore space from constraining those efforts from receiving remuneration [1].

What Is The Bakken Shale Formation?

A geographical map of Bakken Shale formationThe Bakken Shale Formation is an ancient rock formation that dates back to the late Devonian and early Mississippian ages, covering a vast area of approximately 200,000 square miles in the subsurface, including western North Dakota [2]. 

The Bakken Formation lawsuit has become a battleground for conflicting interests as tensions rise between economic growth and environmental protection.

With companies eager to tap into the lucrative oil and gas reserves and environmental groups like the Sierra Club fighting to uphold stringent regulations, the stage is set for a high-stakes legal showdown.

As the case unfolds, the balance between economic development and environmental preservation on the site, including the protection of biological diversity, hangs in the balance.

Related ArticleOil Field Accident Lawsuit Update

Key Players: Companies and Environmental Groups

The Bakken Formation lawsuit involves an array of key players, including:

  • Oil and gas companies
  • Environmental groups
  • The federal government

The Northwest Landowners Association initiated the lawsuit, while the state of North Dakota, the governor, and the attorney general are listed as defendants.

These entities play a crucial role in shaping the Bakken Formation’s legal landscape, as they each bring their unique perspectives and interests.

Bakken Formation Lawsuit Overview

A lawyer reading lawsuit papersThe Bakken Formation lawsuit encompasses various legal proceedings, including allegations, responses, and court decisions.

At its heart lies a dispute over oil leasing in the Bakken Formation, with claims of unauthorized deductions from royalties, non-compliance with the Mineral Leasing Act, and misstatement of oil reserves.

Despite the case’s complexity, the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in North Dakota determined that the lawsuit was correctly dismissed, bringing closure to this Bakken Formation legal saga chapter.

“As the Bakken oil boom matures, North Dakota courts are increasingly encountering questions concerning the validity of oil and gas leases, including whether a lessee’s failure to tender a paid-up lease’s bonus timely constitutes a complete or partial failure of consideration.”
Zachary R. Eiken, ND Attorney in Bismarck

Complaint Alleges: Violations of Federal Law

The crux of the complaint in the Bakken Formation lawsuit lies in the argument that the U.S. government, through the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA), approved the lease purchase before the plan was formulated.

The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) alleged that the companies had made false and misleading statements about their Bakken Formation operations to investors.

The Commission also alleges that the defendants made numerous false and misleading statements to investors of NDDF. For example, they claimed to have partnered with large public oil and gas companies like ConocoPhillips and Continental Resources, Inc.

The defendants have raised an estimated $4 million since at least January 2014 through the fraudulent sale of securities in the Sethi-North Dakota Drilling Fund-LVIII Joint Venture (NDDF).

Attorney General’s Response: Defending the Lease Approval Process

A woman writing some legal documentsIn response to the allegations, the Attorney General maintained that the lease approval process was valid, asserting that the suspension of federal land auctions was essential for the Department of the Interior to conduct an internal assessment of the process.

This defense seeks to uphold the government’s actions and protect the interests of the energy industry.

However, U.S. District Judge Daniel Traynor questioned the rationale behind North Dakota’s lawsuit, pointing out that the federal government was already set to resume leasing in the initial quarter of 2021.

As the legal battle rages on, the Attorney General’s defense of the lease approval process remains a crucial aspect of the case.

Court Decisions and Appeals

Throughout the Bakken Formation lawsuit, numerous court decisions and appeals have taken place, shaping the trajectory of the legal dispute. The 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in North Dakota played a pivotal role in determining the case’s outcome, holding that it was suitably dismissed.

Read AlsoWhat to Expect During an Oilfield Accident Settlement

What Is The Average Settlement Amount In The Lawsuit?

Gavel and some dollar billsThe average settlement amount in the lawsuit varies depending on the individual case; some settlements have been reported at a high value, reaching millions of dollars. 

As the legal dispute evolves, the average settlement amount awarded in the Bakken Formation lawsuit remains a topic of interest for all parties involved.

The amount of the settlement is determined by a variety of factors, including the severity of the settlement.

Related Articles:

See all related personal injury and accident lawsuits our lawyers covered so far.

Choose our lawyers

Have you or a loved one been injured in an accident due to the negligence of others?


What Are The Top Dangers On Bakken Shale Oil Rigs?

The top dangers on Bakken Shale oil rigs include the potential for fire and explosion due to the ignition of flammable vapors or gases, exposure to hazardous chemicals, and the use of heavy machinery. These dangers can result in accidents, injuries, and even fatalities.

What Happened In The Bakken Shale Accidents?

In the Bakken Shale accidents, fatalities, and environmental changes were caused by tanker truck explosions, train derailments, and other oilfield incidents. The precise causes of these accidents are yet to be determined, but they underscore the inherent risks associated with oil and gas extraction in the Bakken Formation.

Get A Free Lawsuit Evaluation With Our Experienced Lawyers

If you believe you have a potential Bakken Formation lawsuit, the experienced attorneys at Schmidt & Clark, LLP are here to help. We offer a complimentary evaluation of your case, providing guidance and support throughout the legal process. 

Don’t hesitate to reach out and take advantage of our expertise in this complex and high-stakes legal arena.



Free Confidential Case Evaluation

Verified 100% Secure SiteTo contact us for a free review of your potential case, please fill out the form below or call us toll free 24 hrs/day by dialing: (866) 588-0600.