Jessie’s Lemon Meringue Pie Recall Lawsuit | 2025 Latest Updates

What’s the Problem?

In early September 2025, Jessie Lord Bakery voluntarily recalled over 136,000 cases of lemon meringue pies—marketed under the Jessie’s and First Street brands—due to the presence of undeclared Yellow #5 food coloring (tartrazine), which may induce allergic reactions in sensitive individuals, particularly those with asthma or aspirin sensitivities.

The recall covers 8-inch, 27-ounce pies distributed across 14 states, including Alabama, California, Florida, New York, and Texas. This recall raises legal concerns related to inadequate labeling, consumer safety, and emotional or physical harm.

Though no serious health incidents have been reported, affected consumers may pursue legal claims for medical evaluation, emotional distress, and other damages.

Currently, no lawsuits are reported, but our firm is investigating the legal viability of claims tied to allergic reactions, lack of disclosure, and emotional or financial distress caused by exposure concerns.

Latest Jessie’s Pie Recall Updates

• September 5, 2025 – FDA announces recall of over 136,000 lemon meringue pies from Jessie Lord Bakery due to undeclared Yellow #5 dye [1]
• September 7, 2025 – Reports confirm that pies were distributed across 14 states, identified by lot codes 24050–25231 and best-by date of February 19, 2027 [2]
• September 8, 2025 – Coverage underscores FDA’s Class II recall classification, noting Yellow #5’s allergy risks and that regulations require its explicit labeling [3]

Recall Statistics

• Products recalled – Over 136,000 lemon meringue pies (Jessie’s and First Street brands)
• Product details – 8″ round pies, 27 oz; Yellow #5 undeclared inclusion
• Lot codes – 24050 through 25231
• Best-by date – February 19, 2027
• States impacted – 14 including CA, TX, FL, NY, AL, VA, PA, WI, etc.
• Recall classification – FDA Class II (potential temporary or reversible health effects)
• Reported incidents – None publicized as of announcement

FDA Safety Concerns & Guidance

Though Yellow #5 (tartrazine) is FDA-approved, its omission from the ingredient list imperils consumers sensitive to it. Reactions can include hives, difficulty breathing, and swelling, especially in individuals with asthma or aspirin sensitivities.

The FDA’s Class II designation signals possible medically reversible consequences. Consumers are advised to avoid consuming the pies and to return or request refunds from the point of purchase.

Potential Injuries & Consequences

Even in absence of confirmed allergies, the undeclared allergen raises serious concerns. Affected consumers may face:

• Allergic reactions such as hives, respiratory symptoms, or anaphylactoid responses
• Anxiety or fear stemming from potential exposure
• Medical expenses for evaluation or treatment
• Replacement costs and inconvenience from disposal and reimbursement

Do You Qualify for a Pie Recall Lawsuit?

• You purchased Jessie’s or First Street lemon meringue pie with matching lot codes and best-by date.
• You experienced an allergic reaction or sought medical evaluation, or incurred cost or stress due to exposure concerns.
• You can document your purchase, product packaging, or proof of disposal and refund efforts.

Evidence Required for a Claim

• Photos of product packaging showing lot codes and labels
• Purchase proof (receipt, loyalty account, or photos)
• Medical records detailing any allergic reactions or evaluation
• Documentation of replacement costs or refund communications
• Personal account of emotional or physical distress caused by exposure

Damages You Can Recover

• Medical treatment and testing costs
• Reimbursement for product disposal or replacement
• Compensation for emotional distress or anxiety
• Lost wages or productivity losses related to exposure
• Punitive damages if gross negligence is established

Recall Summary

• Recall date – September 5, 2025
• Products – Jessie’s and First Street lemon meringue pies
• Hazard – Undeclared Yellow #5 food coloring, allergy risk
• Distribution – 14 states across U.S.
• Action – Do not consume; return for refund

Statute of Limitations

Filing deadlines can range from one to four years depending on your state and type of claim. Acting promptly with legal guidance helps preserve your rights and evidence.

Frequently Asked Questions

• How can I tell if my pie is included? – Check for Jessie’s or First Street branding, lot codes 24050–25231, and the best-by date of Feb 19, 2027.
• Can I eat it if cooked? – No; cooking does not eliminate allergy risk from undeclared Yellow #5.
• Any reported illnesses? – None publicly announced.
• Need receipt for a claim? – Helpful but photos or product retention may suffice.
• Who could be liable? – Possible liability may rest with bakery, distributor, or retailer under consumer protection laws.

References

1. https://www.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/life-style/health-fitness/health-news/fda-recalls-over-136000-lemon-meringue-pies-due-to-food-coloring/articleshow/123755184.cms
2. https://rollingout.com/2025/09/07/pie-recall-hit-14-states-over-ingredient
3. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/us/over-136000-lemon-meringue-pies-recalled-by-california-based-bakery-distributed-across-14-states/articleshow/123754906.cms