What Does Acquitted Mean?Acquitted vs Not Guilty: All the Differences

Schmidt & Clark, LLP is not currently accepting these types of cases and has posted this content for information purposes only. We encourage you to seek a qualified attorney, if you feel you might have a case.

An acquittal can change your life, but what does it really mean for your future? Understanding the difference between being acquitted and being found not guilty is crucial for anyone facing criminal charges.

While both indicate the prosecution failed to prove its case, an acquittal is a formal legal judgment, and "not guilty" reflects a verdict by a jury or judge.

Beyond immediate relief, an acquittal can have lasting effects on your reputation, relationships, and opportunities. As a seasoned criminal defense attorney, I’ll clarify these terms and their significance in shaping your life after a trial.

Quick Summary

An acquittal is a formal legal judgment that the prosecution failed to prove guilt, while "not guilty" is a verdict rendered by a jury or judge after evaluating the evidence.
Both outcomes provide relief from criminal charges, but lingering questions about reputation and public perception may remain.
After an acquittal, individuals should address collateral consequences, clear their name if needed, and consult legal counsel to ensure all matters are resolved.
Acquittals can affect future opportunities, such as employment and relationships, underscoring the importance of proactively managing personal and professional recovery.

Acquitted vs Not Guilty: Is There a Difference?

When navigating the criminal justice system, it is essential to understand the distinction between case dismissal and acquittal.

While both result in the defendant being freed from charges, they differ in terms of timing, process, and legal implications.

Case Dismissal: When the Process Ends Before Trial

A dismissal occurs when a judge terminates the case before it goes to trial. This decision often stems from procedural issues, insufficient evidence, or prosecutorial discretion.

Key Characteristics of Dismissal:

Timing: Dismissals happen before or during the early stages of a trial, often before a jury is involved.
Decision Basis:
- Lack of sufficient evidence to justify proceeding.
- Procedural violations, such as unlawful evidence collection.
- Prosecutorial discretion to drop charges due to weak cases or plea agreements.
Examples:
1. A theft case is dismissed because key evidence was obtained without a proper warrant.
2. Charges for assault are dropped when a crucial witness retracts their testimony.

Legal Implications of Dismissal:

Double Jeopardy Does Not Apply: Since the case was not resolved on its merits, the charges can often be refiled if new evidence emerges.
No Determination of Guilt or Innocence: A dismissal halts proceedings but doesn’t decide whether the defendant committed the alleged crime.

Acquittal: A Judgment of Not Guilty

An acquittal occurs after the trial process concludes, where the judge or jury formally declares that the prosecution failed to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.

Key Characteristics of Acquittal:

Timing: Happens after a trial, once the evidence has been reviewed by the court or jury.
Decision Basis:
- The prosecution could not meet its burden of proof.
- A judge may issue a directed verdict if evidence is insufficient even before the jury deliberates.
Types of Acquittal:
1. Complete Acquittal: The defendant is cleared of all charges.
2. Partial Acquittal: The defendant is found not guilty of some charges but guilty of others.
  - Example: A defendant acquitted of burglary but convicted of trespassing.

Legal Implications of Acquittal:

Double Jeopardy Protection: The defendant cannot be retried for the same crime in the same jurisdiction.
Not a Declaration of Innocence: An acquittal doesn’t mean the defendant is proven innocent; it only means there wasn’t enough evidence to convict.
Real-Life Scenarios:
1. A defendant charged with fraud is acquitted because financial records fail to establish intent to deceive.
2. A defendant is acquitted after a jury finds alibi evidence credible, contradicting the prosecution’s timeline.

Key Differences Between Dismissal and Acquittal

The distinction between dismissal and acquittal lies in their timing and implications. A dismissal halts proceedings before they reach a verdict, often leaving the door open for future prosecution.

In contrast, an acquittal follows a thorough review of the evidence, providing legal closure for the defendant.

Aspect	Dismissal	Acquittal
Timing	Before or early in the trial	After a full trial concludes
Reason	Insufficient evidence, procedural error	Failure to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt
Outcome	Charges may be refiled	Charges cannot be retried under Double Jeopardy
Implication	Case ends without determining guilt	Judgment that prosecution failed to prove guilt

While both dismissal and acquittal result in the defendant being freed from charges, the implications and circumstances surrounding each are vastly different. A dismissal halts the case before a verdict is reached, leaving the possibility of future prosecution.

On the other hand, an acquittal is a formal judgment that the prosecution failed to prove its case, offering protection against retrial for the same crime. Understanding these distinctions is vital for anyone facing criminal charges or navigating the legal system.

Is Acquittal the Same as Charge Dismissal?

No, acquittal is not the same as charge dismissal. A defendant acquitted goes to trial, but the prosecutor fails to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt to the judge or jury.

Rather than waste time and resources, judges are hesitant to proceed with a trial unless there is a reasonable prospect of conviction.

This could mean the defendant will be absolved from any charges or associated penalties.

Criminal defense attorneys can also appeal to judges for dismissal in cases based on legal grounds such as:

The defendant was arrested without probable cause
The prosecution failed to submit the criminal complaint or documents submitted
An unlawful search and seizure were conducted, defying the fundamental right to privacy according to criminal law

Navigating Life After an Acquittal: Understanding Your Rights

Being acquitted of criminal charges is a significant step toward rebuilding your life, but the journey doesn’t end there. Understanding your post-acquittal rights is critical to ensuring you can move forward without unnecessary obstacles.

This section outlines key areas where your acquittal can impact your life, including record management, employment, housing, and professional opportunities.

Record Sealing and Expungement: Protecting Your Privacy

An acquittal doesn’t automatically erase your arrest record, but there are legal avenues to reduce its visibility:

Sealing Records: Many states allow individuals to apply for their arrest records to be sealed after an acquittal. Sealed records are not visible to the public but remain accessible to law enforcement and certain legal entities.
Expungement: Expungement goes further by erasing the record entirely. Eligibility depends on state laws, often requiring a waiting period and a clean record post-acquittal.

Example: In California, acquitted individuals can petition for expungement under Penal Code 1203.4, which can remove the stigma of an arrest from their public record.

Taking these steps can help shield you from potential discrimination in employment, housing, and other areas.

Employment Rights: Moving Forward Professionally

An acquittal can influence your ability to secure and maintain employment:

Protection Against Discrimination: Some states prohibit employers from discriminating based on an arrest record if charges were dismissed or resulted in an acquittal. However, these protections vary by jurisdiction.
Disclosure Requirements: While sealed or expunged records do not need to be disclosed, some employers may ask about prior arrests. Knowing your rights regarding these inquiries is crucial.

Despite the acquittal, lingering perceptions of the charges can pose challenges. Preparing to explain the circumstances during job interviews and seeking legal counsel for additional protections may help mitigate potential issues.

Housing Rights: Securing a Safe Space

Finding housing after an acquittal can present challenges if background checks reveal previous arrests:

Landlord Background Checks: While an acquittal should not affect your housing eligibility, some landlords may view arrest records unfavorably.
Fair Housing Laws: Federal and state laws prohibit discrimination based on protected categories like race and disability. Although these laws do not specifically address acquittals, they offer a foundation for challenging housing-related bias tied to arrest history.

Familiarizing yourself with fair housing protections can help you advocate for fair treatment during rental applications.

Freedom to Travel: Post-Acquittal Mobility

Your acquittal typically restores your right to travel without restrictions:

Domestic and International Travel: After an acquittal, you can generally travel freely within the United States and abroad unless specific legal conditions, such as probation, still apply.
Passport Eligibility: Acquittal does not automatically guarantee a passport, but it removes many barriers. If travel restrictions were imposed during your trial, ensure they are formally lifted following your acquittal.

Taking steps to clarify your travel rights can prevent complications during future trips.

Professional Licensing: Addressing Industry-Specific Concerns

Acquittals may influence your ability to obtain or retain professional licenses:

Licensing Board Reviews: Boards governing professions like healthcare or law enforcement may still review the circumstances of the charges. While an acquittal may work in your favor, the nature of the allegations could impact their decisions.
Disclosure Obligations: Some licensing bodies require applicants to disclose any arrests, regardless of the case outcome. Understanding these requirements is critical for navigating the application process.

Consulting with an attorney can help ensure your acquittal is properly framed during professional reviews.

An acquittal offers a fresh start, but it’s essential to understand and exercise your rights to maximize the opportunities it provides.

From sealing records to navigating employment and housing challenges, being informed empowers you to take control of your future. If you have specific concerns about post-acquittal processes, seeking guidance from a legal professional can help you move forward with confidence.

Can Your Criminal Record Be Affected?

Your criminal record can be affected depending on the outcome of the case.

Criminal Record: Navigating Life After Legal Outcomes

Your criminal record reflects the outcome of your case, and its implications can vary widely depending on whether you were acquitted, dismissed, or entered a plea.

For instance, if a charge is dismissed or acquitted and not guilty is declared, the defendant's criminal record will remain clean as no criminal conviction was recorded.

On the other hand, if you decide to plead guilty and a plea deal is accepted, it will be indicated on your criminal record – but only for that particular offense [2].

Understanding how these outcomes impact your record and the steps you can take to address them is crucial for ensuring a clean slate moving forward.

Impact of Legal Outcomes on Your Record

The way your criminal record is affected depends on the resolution of your case:

Acquittal or Dismissal: If charges are dismissed or you are acquitted and declared not guilty, no criminal conviction will be recorded. This outcome leaves your criminal record clean.
Plea Deals and Guilty Pleas: Accepting a plea deal or pleading guilty results in the offense being recorded on your criminal record for that specific charge. This can have long-term implications on employment, housing, and other opportunities.
Future Implications: Even if acquitted or dismissed, the arrest itself may still appear on your record unless action is taken to clear it.

Expungement and Sealing: Clearing Your Record

Taking proactive steps to remove arrest and charge records is essential for a clean start:

Why Expungement Matters: Without expungement, an arrest—even if it did not lead to a conviction—can appear on background checks, affecting your ability to secure employment, housing, and other rights.
Eligibility: After an acquittal or dismissal, individuals are typically eligible to petition for expungement. Laws vary by state, so it’s important to review local regulations or consult a legal professional.

Steps to Take Post-Trial

If you’ve been found not guilty or had charges dismissed, there are key actions you should take to ensure your record remains clear:

1. Initiate Expungement:

Contact your local court to begin the expungement process.
Provide necessary documentation, such as proof of acquittal or dismissal.

2. Verify Record Accuracy:

Check your criminal record to ensure the case outcome is accurately reflected.
Address any discrepancies with legal counsel if needed.

3. Consult an Attorney:

Seek legal advice to navigate the expungement process and avoid potential pitfalls.

Importance of Addressing Your Record

Neglecting to expunge or seal your record can have serious consequences:

Employment Barriers: Many employers conduct background checks, and even non-convictions can raise concerns.
Housing Restrictions: Some landlords may deny housing applications based on visible arrest records.
Lost Opportunities: Licenses, loans, and other privileges can be impacted by an incomplete record-clearing process.

Fortunately, there are solutions for having your arrest and charges taken off of your permanent record. I recommend that you get your record expunged after your trial.

This is very important to do if you are found not guilty. If you do not do this, you might not be able to get a job, live in certain places, or have other rights.

Related Articles:

Clearing Up Common Misunderstandings About Acquittals

Acquittals and criminal charges often come with misconceptions that can lead to confusion about their legal implications. Clarifying these misunderstandings is essential for those navigating the justice system or seeking to understand their rights post-trial. Below are key misconceptions explained in simple terms.

1. "Not Guilty" Equals Innocence? Think Again

One common misconception is that a "not guilty" verdict equates to the defendant being declared innocent. In reality, a not guilty verdict simply means that the prosecution failed to prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt.

This does not confirm innocence but indicates that the evidence presented was insufficient to meet the high legal standard required for conviction. For example, while the jury may harbor doubts about the defendant’s actions, the lack of concrete evidence prevents a guilty verdict.

2. The Limits of Double Jeopardy Protection

Another widespread misunderstanding involves double jeopardy. Many believe that once acquitted, a person cannot be tried for the same crime again under any circumstances. However, double jeopardy protections apply only within the same jurisdiction.

For instance, an acquittal in state court does not prevent federal authorities from prosecuting the same conduct if it violates federal law. This means that overlapping jurisdictions, such as those involving financial crimes or large-scale offenses, may result in separate legal battles.

3. State vs. Federal Charges: A Separate Battle

An acquittal in state court is often mistakenly seen as the end of legal troubles. In reality, federal authorities may still prosecute the individual if the alleged actions violate federal law.

This is especially common in cases involving drug trafficking, organized crime, or fraud, where state and federal laws intersect. Understanding this distinction is crucial for those facing complex legal proceedings.

4. Civil Lawsuits Don’t End After Acquittal

Many people wrongly assume that being acquitted of a crime protects them from civil lawsuits. However, an acquittal in a criminal trial does not preclude victims from pursuing civil damages.

The burden of proof in civil cases is lower than in criminal trials, making it easier for plaintiffs to succeed. For instance, someone acquitted of assault in a criminal court could still face a civil lawsuit seeking financial compensation for damages or emotional distress caused by their alleged actions.

5. Travel Freedom After Acquittal: Not Always Guaranteed

Travel restrictions post-acquittal are another area of confusion. While an acquittal removes criminal charges, it does not automatically guarantee unrestricted travel. Outstanding warrants, immigration complications, or the stigma associated with past arrests may still create barriers.

Some countries may even deny entry based on arrest records alone, regardless of the trial’s outcome. Understanding these potential hurdles is essential for individuals planning international travel after an acquittal.

If you have questions or need advice specific to your circumstances, consulting a knowledgeable legal professional can provide clarity and tailored guidance.

See all related personal injury and accident lawsuits our lawyers have covered.

FAQs

Can I Get the Charges Dropped?

Yes, it may be possible to get charges dropped. This usually involves negotiations between the prosecution and the criminal defense lawyer to reach an agreement beneficial for both parties, such as reducing the offense or penalty.

What Does It Mean if the Defendant Is Acquitted?

If the defendant is acquitted, the case goes to trial, but the prosecutor failed to demonstrate beyond a reasonable doubt that they had committed the crime. Consequently, due to the lack of evidence presented in court, a case was dismissed, and the proceedings were halted before reaching jury deliberations.

Can a Case Be Reopened After Acquittal?

No case can be reopened after acquittal. Once an individual has been acquitted, pardoned, or found guilty of a specific offense in the trial, they are legally safeguarded from being prosecuted again for the same crime in the same jurisdiction.

What Happens When the Accused Is Acquitted?

When an accused is acquitted, the charges are dropped, and the proceedings are halted without reaching a verdict or jury deliberations. This is usually due to insufficient evidence the prosecution presents that fails to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Consequently, the accused will be released from any remaining criminal liability concerning that particular offense.

What Is the Difference Between Being Acquitted and Being Found Not Guilty?

The difference between being acquitted and being found not guilty is that being acquitted means that a judge or jury has found that there was not enough evidence to convict the defendant, leading to a formal declaration of the defendant's innocence. However, being found not guilty also means that the defendant has been cleared of charges, but it specifically indicates that the prosecution failed to prove the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Talk to a Criminal Defense Lawyer Today

Being tried for a crime can be an overwhelming experience. Fortunately, if you are set free from the accusation due to a lack of evidence or acquittal, your life won't have to remain in disarray forever; there is hope for rebuilding and returning to normal.

At Schmidt & Clark, LLP, our experienced criminal defense lawyers will guide you through your court proceedings.

If you are found innocent or not guilty in a trial, we'll provide comprehensive advice on what this means for your permanent record and future endeavors. Contact us now for a free consultation session.

References:

https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/acquittal#:~:text=An%20acquittal%20is%20a%20resolution,guilty%20of%20the%20charged%20offense.
https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcrmp/rule_11