FREE Case Review (866) 588-0600

Top 5 Signs That a Criminal Case Is Weak
& It Can Be Dismissed

One of the biggest misconceptions people have about criminal cases is that they’re unbeatable. However, only 5-10% of cases actually go to trial, with about 90% of cases being dismissed because they are weak for a variety of reasons.
Awards & recognition
Published by Editor

Schmidt & Clark, LLP is not currently accepting these types of cases and has posted this content for information purposes only. We encourage you to seek a qualified attorney, if you feel you might have a case.

Despite common misconceptions, criminal cases aren't always unbeatable. Only a small percentage, around 5-10%, make it to trial, and many others are dismissed due to various weaknesses. As a criminal defense attorney who is familiar with criminal law, I've seen how these cases unfold and the potential outcomes.

Our articles aim to illuminate legal matters, drawing on our expertise to provide guidance. If you're facing a criminal charge, seeking advice from a qualified attorney is crucial.

Quick Summary:

  • The top 5 signs indicating a weak criminal case include an unlawful arrest, lack of evidence, no credible witnesses, errors in the criminal complaint, and a valid legal defense for the defendant.
  • Only 5-10% of criminal cases make it to trial, and many are dismissed, reduced, or settled favorably for the defendant due to weaknesses in the police or prosecution's case.
  • The most reliable evidence is physical evidence, while the weakest is circumstantial evidence.

Top 5 Signs that a Criminal Case is Weak

Many criminal charges are dismissed, reduced, or settled on terms favorable to the defendant due to weaknesses on the part of the police or prosecution.

The top 5 signs of a weak criminal case include:

  1. An unlawful arrest
  2. Lack of evidence
  3. No credible witnesses
  4. Errors in the criminal complaint
  5. Valid legal defense for the defendant

What is the Most Reliable Type of Evidence?

The most reliable type of evidence is physical evidence. It can corroborate or refute witness testimony, establish connections between individuals and crime scenes, and aid in reconstructing the sequence of events for criminal conviction. "Physical evidence" encompasses tangible items found at crime scenes that can be touched or held.

What is the Weakest Type of Evidence?

The weakest type of evidence is circumstantial evidence. It is indirect evidence that suggests the commission of a crime without directly proving a key fact. 

The drawback of circumstantial evidence lies in its indirect nature: it requires assembling various pieces to determine whether they collectively lead to a reasonable conclusion about probable cause for the fact in question.

Also Read: Can Affidavit Be Used as Evidence?

What is the Hardest Thing to Prove?

The hardest thing to prove is intent. Since intent is a mental state, it poses a significant challenge in court proceedings. In most cases, there is no direct evidence of a defendant's intent, as few individuals admit to committing a crime. Therefore, to establish criminal intent, the judge or the prosecution often relies heavily on circumstantial evidence.

How Much Evidence is Needed to Convict Someone?

The amount of evidence needed to convict someone is substantial. Specifically, the police officer or prosecutor must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the crime they are charged with.

To accomplish this, they must prove:

  • That the person engaged in criminal behavior
  • That they had the state of mind required for that crime

The prosecutor might opt to dismiss more severe accusations in return for a guilty plea to reduced charges. Additionally, the prosecution's strongest evidence could be deemed inadmissible. 

This occurrence may arise if the evidence was procured without a valid warrant, underscoring the significance of understanding one's rights concerning warrants and their procurement.

What is the Hardest Crime to Prosecute?

The hardest crime to prosecute is first-degree murder. This charge is particularly challenging due to its severity and the requirement of proving premeditation, which involves prosecutors demonstrating that the defendant planned the victim's death, also known as malice aforethought.

Related Article: Tort vs Criminal Law

Get a Free Lawsuit Evaluation With Our Lawyers

The Product Liability Litigation Group at our law firm is an experienced team of criminal defense attorneys focusing on criminal defense and plaintiffs' representation in lawsuits. We handle individual litigation nationwide and are currently accepting new legal challenges in all 50 states.

If you or a loved one was injured, contact our law firm immediately for a free case evaluation. You may be entitled to a settlement by filing a suit, and we can help.