FREE Case Review (866) 588-0600

San Juan Basin Lawsuit Overview

Awards & recognition
C.L. Mike Schmidt Published by C.L. Mike Schmidt
Free Consultation
If you or a loved one think you may have a claim, you should contact a personal injury lawyer immediately.

You may be entitled to recover compensation and our legal team can help. Please click the button below for a Free Consultation or call us toll-free 24 hrs/day for legal advice by dialing (866) 588-0600.

Start My Free Case Evaluation

The San Juan Basin lawsuit has captured the attention of environmentalists, the oil and gas industry, and concerned citizens alike.

As a legal battle unfolds between environmental groups and the federal government, the outcome could not only impact the future of the San Juan Basin but also set a precedent for other environmental lawsuits. 

As a legal attorney with almost a decade of experience in environmental law, I have been closely following the San Juan Basin case. In this article, I will discuss the current situation of the lawsuit, as well as its potential implications on environmental law. 

Quick Summary

  • The San Juan Basin is a geological treasure trove home to the San Juan National Forest and an energy production hotspot.
  • The lawsuit against oil & gas drilling in the area has potential implications for future environmental disputes, including stricter regulations and increased scrutiny of industry operations.
  • Environmental groups are committed to continuing efforts for stronger regulation, raising public awareness, and seeking damages/remedies through legal action.

What Is The San Juan Basin?

San Juan Basin geographical mapSan Juan Basin is a geological treasure trove, rich in natural resources such as coal, oil, and natural gas, nestled in the Four Corners region of the Southwest United States [1].

The area is also home to the San Juan National Forest, a breathtaking expanse of ponderosa pine trees and rare mature forests. 

This unique combination of natural beauty and abundant resources has made the San Juan Basin a hotspot for energy production, with multiple stakeholders, including the Forest Service, overseeing its management to benefit the local economy and environment.

The San Juan Basin is a source of valuable natural resources and a vital habitat for various endangered species, making it of particular interest to environmental groups [2]. 

What Happened At The San Juan Basin?

Oil rig at the San Juan BasinThe San Juan Basin has been subjected to extensive oil and gas drilling, resulting in many environmental issues.

Air and water pollution, habitat destruction, loss of old-growth trees, a few large trees, and mature trees, and negative impacts on local communities and forest resilience have been documented as a direct result of these drilling activities.

The once-pristine San Juan National Forest has been marred by a sprawling network of drilling sites and infrastructure, leaving the area’s wild places and public health at risk.

As concerns about the environmental impact of drilling in the San Juan Basin grew, several lawsuits emerged in the district court, addressing issues ranging from timber sales disputes to oil and gas permitting violations.

One such case, the CJ’s Diner lawsuit, involved allegations of constitutional rights violations by state and local public health orders; however, the judge dismissed the case as it did not directly impact the healthy forests in the San Juan Basin. 

This set the stage for the high-profile San Juan Basin lawsuit involving environmental groups and the federal government, where the Salter timber project violated regulations.

San Juan Basin Lawsuit Overview

At the heart of the San Juan Basin lawsuit is a legal dispute between environmental organizations, such as the San Juan Basin Royalty Trust and the San Juan Citizens Alliance, and the federal government. 

The main issue of the case is that there is an accusation that the government, which includes the Forest Service, did not properly assess the environmental effects of oil and gas drilling in the San Juan Basin. 

The outcome of this lawsuit, in which the Forest Service presided over a massive timber sale, could hold it accountable for its actions, setting a precedent for future legal disputes concerning the environment and the federal government.

Allegations in the San Juan Basin Lawsuit

Gavel and lawsuit papersThe environmental groups argue that the federal government has violated the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) by not thoroughly assessing the environmental impacts of oil and gas drilling in the San Juan Basin. 

NEPA is a federal law that requires the government to evaluate the environmental effects of any proposed action that could significantly impact the environment, such as oil and gas drilling activities in the region [2].

The lawsuit claims that the government’s failure to fulfill its obligations under NEPA has led to considerable environmental damage, including air and water pollution, habitat destruction, and potential groundwater contamination, all of which can negatively affect the rare mature forests found in the area.

“We sat down with the Forest Service, wrote their comments, and repeatedly urged them to use the best available science and adopt an alternative that protected large trees, but they ignored us every step. We’ve been forced to ask a federal court to uphold the law and protect the wildlife, recreation, and natural values important to residents and visitors across the nation.”
John Rader, Public Lands Program Manager at the Durango-based San Juan Citizens Alliance

Legal Issues and Federal Court Decisions

The legal issues in the San Juan Basin lawsuit center around the federal government’s inadequate assessment of the environmental impacts of oil and gas drilling in the area and the potential violation of the National Forest Management Act.

Throughout the lawsuit, federal courts have ruled in favor of the environmental groups, requiring the government to reevaluate its approach to oil and gas drilling in the San Juan Basin.

These court decisions have forced the government to reconsider its management of the area’s natural resources. They could better protect the San Juan Basin’s large trees and unique ecosystems.

Implications of the San Juan Basin Lawsuit

The implications of the San Juan Basin lawsuit extend beyond the immediate parties involved. The case could have far-reaching consequences for the oil and gas industry, potentially leading to stricter regulations, increased scrutiny, and financial repercussions for companies operating in the San Juan Basin.

Next Steps for Environmental Groups

A lawyer reading a documentWhile the outcome of the San Juan Basin lawsuit remains uncertain, environmental groups are unlikely to rest on their laurels.

Regardless of the final verdict, these organizations will likely continue to push for stronger regulations and increased oversight of oil and gas drilling in the San Juan Basin, aiming to protect the environment and local communities from the detrimental effects of drilling operations.

In the wake of the lawsuit, environmental groups may also seek to raise public awareness of the issues at stake, rallying support for their cause and pressuring lawmakers and regulators to enact meaningful change.

What Is The Average Payout For San Juan Basin Lawsuits?

A wallet and gavel on top of dollar bills

The average payout for San Juan Basin lawsuits can vary greatly depending on the specific circumstances of each case.

The following factors can all influence the final payout: 

  • The amount of damages sought.
  • The strength of the evidence
  • The jurisdiction in which the case is heard 
  • The amount of legal fees incurred 

Despite the difficulty pinpointing an average payout, we can look at examples of settlements and verdicts from past San Juan Basin lawsuits for insight.

For instance, a case involving water contamination resulted in a $2.5 million settlement, while another case involving air pollution led to a $1.5 million settlement. 

In yet another case concerning groundwater contamination, the verdict was $3.5 million. These examples demonstrate the wide range of potential outcomes in San Juan Basin lawsuits, highlighting the importance of considering each case on its merits.

Related Articles:

See all related personal injury and accident lawsuits our lawyers have taken on.

Choose our lawyers

Have you or a loved one been injured in an accident due to the negligence of others?


What Environmental Issues Have Been Documented Due To Oil And Gas Drilling In The San Juan Basin?

The environmental issues that have been documented due to oil and gas drilling in the San Juan Basin include air, water, and habitat pollution, as well as detrimental effects on local communities and forest resilience.

What Potential Regulatory Changes Could Be Implemented In Response To The San Juan Basin Lawsuit?

The potential regulatory changes that could be implemented in response to the San Juan Basin Lawsuit include stricter wastewater management, increased monitoring of oil and gas operations, and stricter enforcement of environmental laws.

Contact Our Roundup Attorneys And Receive A Free Evaluation Of Your Lawsuit

If you believe you have a potential lawsuit related to the San Juan Basin, our experienced attorneys are here to help.

Contact Schmidt & Clark, LLP today for a free evaluation of your case and guidance on your legal options.

From evaluating your legal options to recommending additional resources, our dedicated attorneys are committed to supporting you throughout the legal process. 



Free Confidential Case Evaluation

Verified 100% Secure SiteTo contact us for a free review of your potential case, please fill out the form below or call us toll free 24 hrs/day by dialing: (866) 588-0600.